Gender and Feminist Criticism in Oryx and Crake
Written by
Cathy Jing
Jimmy, throughout his entire life,
has not once been in a healthy relationship with a woman. As a child, he
tormented his mother just to satisfy his thirst for attention. He never really
like Ramona, his step-mother. He loved Oryx dearly, but the relationship
clearly was not mutual because she had an affair with Crake as well. The most
detrimental relationships, however, are all of the affairs in between that were
not with girlfriends, but with lovers—married women who wanted Jimmy on the
side. Through these relationships, both men and women are stereotyped, though
women are more than men.
Although it seems that men are
stereotyped as sex machines, upon closer examination, it seems that women are
as well. In this section, Jimmy begins to romp around with married women,
instead of dating his classmates or, at least, women of his age. He uses the
thrill of the impromptu visits and the secrecy to fulfill his sexual desires.
These affairs become so much of his life that he feels restless and “jerked
around by his own dick, as if the rest of him was merely an inconsequential
knob” (Atwood 306). Although Jimmy feels no emotional connection to these
women, he will continue these relationships to fulfill this masculine aspect of
him.
The women in these relationships are
no different. While, in general, women are treated as sexual objects (will
explain later), they, too, commit adultery to satisfy their needs. In fact, the
women used these relationships for sex. As Jimmy says, they only care about him
from the waist down (344).
The purpose of equating this
animalistic role to both men and women is to further support the necessity for
Crake’s remedy for mankind. He believed that humans were flawed because there were
too many sexual frustrations or aggression, which prevented, biologically
speaking, their mating frequencies. By showing that both men and women are like
this, it provides reason to Crake’s viral “solution” in the story. (To the
reader, of course, whether his virus is a clear solution is debatable.) Through
this element of Oryx and Crake, Atwood could even be stating an opinion
of her own. In society, sexual desires are more often found in males than in
females, or, at least, the topic is usually equated with males. By showing that
females are no different, Atwood may be urging us to think more openly about
it.
Feminist criticism is the
patriarchal belief that criticizes female stereotyping, especially qualities
that repress or degrade women. One common critique in literature is the
treatment of women as objects. This is exactly how women are portrayed in the
last section of Oryx and Crake. In general, Jimmy uses women to satisfy
his sexual desires. In fact, “he no longer thought of these women as
girlfriends: now they were lovers. They were all married or the equivalent […]
There was no reason he couldn’t have several of them at once, as long as he was
conscientious about his scheduling” (303). Jimmy is inconsiderate towards these
women, first, because he is committing adultery (even though this is mutual, it
is not okay). However, Jimmy justifies himself as long as his other partners
don’t find out. He completely disregards the potential of hurting them, and
treats them as objects he can use.
Jimmy is
also highly judgmental of women and their appearances; he is, again, viewing
them as objects rather than people. He looks down upon, especially, the
scientist women at Watson-Crick Institute. He didn’t “think much of the
Watson-Crick women on offer” (247). He thinks the world revolves around him and
that there must always be a line of women around him that he can date. By
saying this, he disregards these women’s engineering careers at Watson-Crick,
and reduces them to potential lovers. He furthers his disdain for these women
when they don’t react to his sexual approaches: “Considering their
slovenliness, their casual approach to personal hygiene and adornment, they
ought to have fainted at the attention" (248). This perfectly outlines the
criticism that society is male-dominant and that the men think they are above
the women. By saying this, Jimmy thinks the women at the institute should
admire Jimmy’s advances, and swoon at him because they are not used to the
attention. Again, he fails to realize that the women at the institute are meant
to fulfill men’s desires, which is a very historical way of thinking. He not
only bases his opinion of these women on their appearance, but also disregards
their intelligence and their capabilities. Society, now, has certainly moved on
from these misogynistic views.
I don’t
think these views are Atwood’s own opinions. Although she is characterizing the
world as patriarchal, she doesn’t necessarily believe in them. Stereotyping men
and women is just evidence that Crake’s solution is actually based on the
sexual qualities of humans. The Handmaid’s Tale was written like this as
well. Although Gilead reduced women to mere breeders, the foreboding messages
about feminism show that she obviously does not think women should be treated
as objects. As for objectifying women, I think this is just a cautious warning
that society might eventually become like Jimmy’s attitude towards women.
Atwood, Margaret. Oryx and Crake. Toronto: Seal Books, 2004. Print
"Again, he fails to realize that the women at the institute are meant to fulfill men’s desires, which is a very historical way of thinking."
ReplyDeleteThat's a funny thing to say :)
Besides that, though, solid blog post. I do have a couple comments, though: Firstly, I'm not sure that I'd consider Jimmy's affairs inconsiderate to his "lovers" simply because they are adulterous. You say it's inconsiderate to them, because even though it's mutual, cheating isn't okay. Cheating isn't okay, but involving yourself in that is inconsiderate to the woman's husband, not the woman. She's made her choice; the husband is the one who suffers for it.
Moreover, I don't think these women were being depicted as objects. Jimmy certainly uses them, but they use him, too. There's a difference between how Jimmy views someone and how the book depicts them. In fact, I think these might be the most balanced relationships Jimmy's ever had. It used to be that he'd take advantage of women willing to become emotionally invested in him, use them, and then cast him aside—now, at least, no one has any illusion that they aren't being used. Jimmy has multiple partners, his partners have multiple partners... It's dirty, nasty and immoral, but it can't be accused of sexism, 'cuz everyone's equally awful.
You're spot on about Watson-Crick, though. I agree completely—it's gross how he views the world in terms of its relationship to his dick. It shows how a protagonist isn't necessarily a good person, just the person telling the story.
To expand on both of your points, I think that the selfishness in both women and men in Oryx and Crake is more to do with Atwood’s view of human nature than it is to do with her view of either men or women and their roles in our society. I agree with you Felipe that this is not really a sexist society. Both Jimmy and Crake are very sexist (for example Crake saying that “female artists are biologically confused” (168)), but the women Jimmy encounters seem equally ignorant of the other sex (with the exception of Oryx, of course). I also agree with you Cathy, I don’t think that Atwood is providing her personal views on either sex. Of course, I don’t think that she thinks women are nothing but sex machines, and I highly doubt that she wants to portray men (at least teenage boys) negatively because they are so sex craven that they watch child porn regularly. By showing episodes like these, I think she is sending a similar message to one she did in The Handmaid’s Tale: that people have become accustomed to a new set of values, that humans have no inherent morals. In none of Jimmy’s relationships does either of the sides heave genuine emotions for the other. Either Jimmy or the woman in question (usually both) has a specific goal other than love or genuine connection. This is a result of both the valuing of science and the fact that capitalism is the governing set of values. People disregard the human consequences associated with their actions. As a result of these values, Jimmy doesn’t care that his lover is affected by his games because he is only concerned with what he wants. We see the effect that can have on a person when he is on the receiving end of such behaviour at Anoo Yoo.
ReplyDeleteHello group! I have been enjoying all of your posts. In case any of you enjoyed the novel but found it lacking in representing the female perspective, you might be interested in the sequels that focus mainly on female protagonists who made brief appearances in this novel.
ReplyDelete